Friday, January 14, 2011

The Science of Dating

Want to cure cancer? Here, apply to this university, study these exams, get into stem cell research, and you’re on your way! Want to travel to the moon? No problem. Follow this course, pass the selection committee, become an astronaut and you’re off! Want success in the dating world? Well, you’ll just have to figure that one out all by yourself. Don’t worry though, there’s tons of advice out there. Unfortunately for you, the fact that there is a lot of advice available complicates things even more. As you’ll quickly realize, even grandma’s got her own special little anecdote dating knowledge that she lived by. To make matters worse, most professionals giving advice in this field don’t mind contradicting each other either, because, after all, it’s worked for them, right? Consider the following examples: be friendly and nice, but don’t forget to play hard to get; be funny, but don’t get ridiculed; be tolerant of differences, but be decisive and firm; and so the list goes on... And hey, while you’re at it, just be yourself!

Obviously, the need of an educated opinion on the subject would benefit just about any human on this planet. What healthy minded individual wouldn’t enjoy the feeling of being wanted? With that in mind, what would a science of dating consist of? Slowly but surely, we’re starting to see the emergence of reoccurring themes and patterns in the field of applied social psychology that could give us a glimpse at what its theoretical frame would look like. First, a science of dating, and the inevitable sex, of course, has to include a very thorough and fundamental view of human nature and its purpose. After all, you are here in this very moment reading this text because you are the product of thousands of births before yours! Second, it is important that attraction is thoroughly defined and understood so that we can identify attractiveness and how it is perceived. Also, this is where we gradually narrow the focus from the human species as a whole, to gender differences. Third, a science of dating would be complete by determining the possible strategies that are used in modern dating situations. Unlike traditional psychology which focused only on the cure for illnesses and not optimal health, this section should be able to help those who have dating deficiencies as well as help the ‘average Joe’ in achieving a higher degree of success. And, similarly to any science, being specific in the application of the theory is critical; having the ingredients of a pill that could turn a frog into a prince is useless if we can’t make a pill that the frog can digest!

Understanding human courtship in the context of modern dating represents a difficult task that has everything to do with the existence of humans. Anyone who has been confronted with an overly curious child asking a barrage of ‘why’ questions knows not to underestimate this philosophical inquiry. Unfortunately for the case of scientific studies, a researcher can’t simply tell his audience to ‘ask daddy’ when the questions become increasingly difficult. So, without further procrastination, a science of dating inevitably asks the following question: what motivates a human, or any animal for that matter, to seek out a mate to reproduce with? According to the book Selfish Gene by Richard Dawkins, the end goal would be the preservation of our genes by assuring their survival through time. To fully understand the implications of such a statement and what it means to the dating world, human behavior has to be observed in the context of evolution which was the basis of Dawkins’ ideas. Charles Darwin, commonly known as the father of evolutionary theories, introduced the concept of natural selection in his work On the Origin of the Species (1859) and further elaborated sexual selection in his work The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex (1871). In other words, the important parts of both concepts, natural and sexual selection, with Dawkins’ spin on it can be incorporated in the explanation of human behavior as serving two purposes: the survival and replication of our genes. Consequently, this means that anything that is desirable, including dating partners, can be measured by different levels of survival or replication value.

Now that we’ve built a foundation on which we can build our doctrine of human romance, it’s time to write up the blue print and find out how it relates to our immediate reality. If a gene-centered Darwinian theory on evolution is supposed to represent a rough sketch of a dating theory blue print, you might be under the impression that you’re holding it upside down. That’s because you need to know the rules of the trade, much like an architect does before writing up his blue print. To explain the required considerations, the use of Dawkins’ mechanical analogy and argumentation seems best suited since it conveys meaning in simpler terms without losing intricate detail. For starters, we are imperfect survival machines. It’s important to know that everything we do is a product of programming that was intended to help us survive and replicate regardless of what the end results are. An example of this is purposely breaking the thin layer of ice of a freshly frozen puddle in the street. This action doesn’t help an individual survive or replicate in any way, but the behavior is a by-product of the processes indirectly linked to survival. Then, hypothetically, the made-up ‘instinct of puddle ice breaking’ would be a collateral effect of wanting to learn the environment and how it reacts to human interaction, which historically would have their benefits to survival in other circumstances. In addition, according to Dawkins, we are also very outdated survival machines. Our biological machine is intended to help us survive and replicate in a harsh natural environment. As you can see, the world might have changed immensely in the past decades but your body hasn’t. An example of this is found in attitudes towards sex which are still biologically oriented around the fact that it causes pregnancy, even though newly invented contraception has eliminated that consequence.

Having answered the fundamental question of why we date, we can finally proceed and answer more specific questions. To provide a comprehensive answer, social psychology now joins in with evolutionary biology. Incorporating social psychology into our newly created laws of love has everything to do with what we look for in other people. Among other contributions, psychology has shown us that we are not consciously aware of what we truly want. A study conducted by Eastwick & Finkel (2008) had their participants list their mate preferences and then chose their favorite candidate out of a speed dating exercise. Results have shown that preferences failed to predict the candidate chosen. This is not to suggest that people are completely oblivious to what they desire, but there seems to be an element to attraction that to be out of conscious control. Also, what we want does not follow rational choice. Remember the old saying ‘not even if you were the last person on earth’? Well, hopefully you weren’t the target of this saying because there could actually be truth in that statement. A study conducted by Cohen, Peres & Kanazawa (2008) has shown that women remain selective even when the male to female ratio is low. Observing the effects of an extreme ratio such as 4 billion to one, however, could prove to be slightly different. In conclusion, there are many other contributions from social psychology and they should all be incorporated carefully, with each study’s weaknesses in mind.

Most frustrations from the world of dating come from misunderstanding the opposite sex by assuming that they think the same way you do. Analyzing a substantial amount of literature on gender differences regarding attitudes towards sex (Oliver, & Hyde, 1993), for example, shows that the sexes do not think alike. Conflict between sexes, in this case, is unavoidable and even part of a natural process according to intersexual selection, which is the scientific term for competition between sexes in a certain species (Darwin, 1871). Now, we can see that the toilet seat dispute (up or down?) is only the tip of the battle of the sexes iceberg! No doubt that the war between genders can’t be won, but understanding the differences between you and your partner can reduce the warfare in your relationship. One thing that can cause friction inside a relationship is the misunderstanding of certain unfair double standards present between the sexes. To keep things fair on the playing field, both sides will be considered in the examples contained in the following paragraphs.

Most people are aware of the stereotype that a guy who ‘scores’ is better viewed by society than a woman who was involved in the same sexual act. Although the phenomenon does not have a proper scientific term, Leveque et al. (2007) have conducted an experiment to test it. The method required participants to rate photographs containing members of the opposite sex on a 1-10 attractiveness scale after they’ve been informed various information including the hint that the person had engaged in intercourse with multiple partners. The results have shown that men perceived women less attractive once they’ve been informed of their promiscuity than women rated men when informed of the same information. This perfectly demonstrates the existence of a double standard turning the stereotype into documented fact. Again, this hypothesis initially found its roots in evolutionary psychology. Logically, in ancient times, if a woman had multiple partners it would mean that she had several children that needed care. On one hand, it is simply counter-intuitive to think that a man would devote time and resources to help raise the children of several other biological fathers. After all, from Dawkins’ gene-centered evolutionary point of view, the absence of biological fathers might signal a warning that they might have esteemed her genetic fitness as being inadequate. On the other hand, if she did not give birth to any children, this constituted a sign of infertility or disease, which are two very aversive traits. Following natural selection, men who preferred women with multiple partners simply had their genes weeded out of existence. Now remember, this in an ancient context without the invention of contraception. In the 21st century, the laws don’t necessarily apply logically, but our systems are already hard-wired to shower disdain on promiscuous females regardless.

Not to stop men in their tracks, but being a man does have its disadvantages also (believe it or not). When it comes to calling the shots, women are the choosier sex by nature. Evolutionary biology predicted this since a woman normally invests 9 months of her life to pregnancy following sexual intercourse, as opposed to the minimal investment made by the male. This prediction was validated by empirical research in the field of psychology across cultures and continents (Tadinac, & Hromatko, 2004; Geher, Derieg, & Downey, 2004). That’s right guys; you all get the short end of the stick for this one. This places men in the hunter’s shoes, courting the woman to display his genetic fitness to the female. And that, according to Buss & Shackelford (2008), is not an easy task since attractive women have high standards on all four qualities that trigger attraction:

(1) hypothesized good-gene indicators (e.g., masculinity, sexiness); (2) hypothesized good investment indicators (e.g., potential income); (3) good parenting indicators (e.g., desire for home and children), and (4) good partner indicators (e.g., being a loving partner). (p. 134)

Men, however, do have the same attraction triggers, but they are of lesser relevance for certain areas. For instance, in a study led by Rechek, Remiker, Swanson, & Zeug (2006), male participants were asked to judge the attractiveness of a woman photographed in two situations, one where she was interacting with a baby and another where the baby was ignored while distressed. The results showed that the males had no significant preference in the picture, whereas women were impacted favorably in the same context of a man photographed interacting with a baby.

Most men will tell you that women’s demands are unrealistic, and they’re maybe right! They’re also being one-sided, because men’s demands are also unrealistic, just in different areas. Inevitably, these expectations are not only damaging to the one who has them, but also to the partner who can’t live up to them. Everyone dreams of perfection but the sad reality is that there are compromises to be made if you want the best genetic ‘deal’ you can afford. Before you head out in the dating market, here are the rules of the game: attractiveness is always perceived and not definite, which means you can always increase your reproductive ‘value’ through your behavior, and also, no one, including yourself, knows their true reproductive value and must base their estimations on feedback and past experiences (Fawcett & Bleay, 2009). Also, the ‘prices’ change depending on what you’re looking for. As stated previously, men have lower short term relationship thresholds than women. In fact, when an invitation for casual sex was made by a complete stranger, 75% of the men accepted, whereas 100% of the women rejected the offer (Clark, & Hatfield, 1989). Agreed, women’s height of standards do not vary as much between the short and the long term, but both sexes agree on one thing, physical attractiveness is more valued in the short term (Li, & Kenrick, 2006). However, we had already established that physical attractiveness was part of the healthy gene indicators (Buss, & Shakelford, 2008), so it would be a good idea to revise the female short term preferences to see if masculinity can replace physical attractiveness or if masculinity is a luxury once the attractiveness threshold is attained.

The only thing left to the science of dating would be the elaboration of a program that would focus on demonstrating the key attractive qualities in everyday conversation. For men, casually mentioning a trick your niece showed you last weekend while playfully playing it on a woman, for example, would constitute a good parenting indicator. However, the intricacies of conversation rely not only upon words, making the program incomplete if it doesn’t include a seminar on appropriate body language. It’s important that the subtext communicated does not betray the explicit words you say. Although such programs exist for men, such as the Mystery Method (2007) by Eric Horvat-Markovic, there appears to be no other equivalent programs for women except magazines. A program elaborated from a complete body of research should be capable of helping both sexes in attaining realistic dating goals set by each. If formal classes were to emerge from these efforts, it would be interesting to see what effects this would have to society as a whole. Maybe ‘date-ology’ could become a personal seminar, such as the case of cutting edge sales techniques, or it could become a university course taught to eager students all over the world! Standardizing this in high school, however, would involve a very tricky paradox: if absolutely everyone were to improve their dating skills, we’d essentially be dating the same genetic losers we’re designed to avoid, only disguised in a shiny new wrapping!






References



Buss, D. M., Shackelford, T. K. (2008). Attractive women want it all: Good genes, economic investment, parenting proclivities, and emotional commitment. Evolutionary Psychology, 6(1), 134-146.

Clark, R. D., & Hatfield, E. (1989). Gender differences in receptivity to sexual offers. Journal of Psychology and Human Sexuality, 2, 39–55.

Cohen, Y. B., Peres, Y., & Kanazawa, S. (2008). Rational choice and evolutionary psychology as explanations for mate selectivity. Journal of Social, Evolutionary, and Cultural Psychology, 2(2), 42-55.

Darwin, C. (1859). On the Origin of the Species by Means of Natural Selection. London: John Murray, Albermarle street.

Darwin, C. (1871). The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex London: John Murray, Albermarle street.

Dawkins, R. (1989). The Selfish Gene. Oxford University Press; Oxford.

Eastwick, P. W., Finkel, E. J. (2008). Sex differences in mate preference revisited: Do people know what they initially desire in a romantic partner? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 94(2), 245-264.

Fawcett, T. W., & Bleay, C. (2009). Previous experiences shape adaptive mate preferences. Behavioral Ecology, 20(1), 68-78.

Geher, G., Derieg, M., & Downey, H. (2004, March). Required parental investment and mating patterns: A quantitative analysis in the context of evolutionarily stable strategies. Social Biology, 51(1), 54-70.

Horvat-Markovic, E. J. (2007). The Mystery Method: How to Get Beautiful Women Into Bed. St. Martins Press; New York.

Levesque, M., Vichesky, D., Simmons, M., Wicke, K. & Lipe, A. (2007). Physical attractiveness and sex in judgments about perceived sexually promiscuous others. Psychological Reports,100(3-2), 1107-1112.

Li, N., & Kenrick, D. (2006, March). Sex similarities and differences in preferences for short-term mates: What, whether, and why. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90(3), 468-489.

Norman, L. P., & Douglas, K. T. (2006). Sex similarities and differences in preferences for short-term mates: What, whether, and why. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90(3), 468-489.

Rechek, A. B., Remiker, M. W., Swanson, M. R., & Zeug, N. M., (2006). Women More than Men Attend to Indicators of Good Character: Two Experimental Demonstrations. Evolutionary Psychology, 4, 248-261.

Rushton, J. P., & Bons, T. A. (2005). Mate Choice and Friendship in Twins: Evidence for Genetic Similarity. Psychological Science, 16(7), 555-559.

Tadinac, M., & Hromatko, I. (2004). Sex differences in mate preferences: Testing some predictions from evolutionary theory. Review of Psychology, 11(1), 45-51.

2 comments:

  1. Oh man, that is a lot of helpful information, keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete
  2. that was very useful!
    Anyways, cool blog, I'll follow and support :)

    ReplyDelete